eng

Blogs

“Grey" economy: what lessons can be learned from the world experience?

16 July, 2020

site

Dilyara Yakupova

Analyst

Why is the question of the "grey" (or informal) economy relevant especially now? COVID-19 has again revealed the vulnerability of millions of people who make a living in the informal economy. This serves as a reminder of the need to properly understand and target the problem of the “grey" economy.

The informal sector represents about one third of GDP in developing countries. "Informality" is more common in low-income countries with a large agricultural sector and a high proportion of unqualified workers.

The issue of the grey economy is also very relevant for Kazakhstan. According to the Committee on Statistics , the share of the grey economy in GDP is 27%* and remains consistently high from year to year.

Despite the fact that in some countries the benefits of flexibility and employment in the informal sector are highlighted, usually the growth of this sector coincide with lower productivity, lower tax revenues, and increased poverty and inequality.

Many countries have made attempts to fight the "grey matter".  A large-scale RNSF** project conducted a global review of country policies to counteract the informal economy. Let's consider some of their main conclusions. Despite the fact that governments use different approaches that target grey activity, there are 3 main groups of approaches.

1) taxation of informal activities
Of course, the issue of taxation of the informal economy (due to its high share in GDP) is one of the main “concerns” of governments. No matter how paradoxical it may sound, a properly constructed taxation system may become an occasion for revival and renewal of the social contract between society and the state. That is why it is of fundamental importance to link taxation to the mechanism of clear and effective redistribution of resources to the benefit of citizens (access to social protection and all other services provided by the state). This could be a powerful tool for the reintegration of vulnerable and marginalized segments, providing a unique opportunity to re-establish their trust in the state.

2) Informal activities in the value chain
Value chain interventions aimed at supporting vulnerable groups mobilize mechanisms to fight the informal sector (especially in agriculture). For example, interventions require organizing these groups; facilitate social protection coverage because they also require access to credit, innovations and other opportunities in the "formal" sector. Finally, they are a powerful tool to revitalize rural areas through constructing and strengthening linkages between the informal and formal economies.

3) Organizing people who depend on the informal economy
The informal sector is also difficult to analyze and understand when workers in the "grey area" are dispersed and invisible in the eyes of policy makers.  No universal model is suitable for everyone in terms of organizing informal workers, as this group of workers is quite diversified, but this has been useful in some countries:
- changing the mindset of policy makers so that informal workers could be acknowledged and confirmed as real workers (despite different forms of employment relationships or arrangements);
- changes in laws and regulations to protect and promote the rights of informal workers

Finally, the formalization of the informal economy can be achieved through a gradual process. It should be noted that overcoming the problems of the "grey" sector requires a comprehensive approach and a balanced combination of policies that carefully take into account the specifics of a particular country and, of course, the interests of the “grey”employees themselves.

*as of 2018
** Research, Network & Support Facility Project , sponsored by the EU
 
Sources:
1) CS under MNE of RK;
2) Policies on the informal economy: A global review. 2018. RNSF;
3)    Global Economic Prospects. Topical issue – informality. 2019. World Bank;
4)    COVID-19 crisis and the informal economy. 2020. International Labour Organization.

 

all publications

Reports

more

Blogs

more

News

more
site