Blogs
Are Kazakhstani people ready for progress?
June 17, 2019
Kuanysh Zhaikov
partner
Over the past 15-20 years, many attempts have been made to carry out reforms and implement government programs. Much of what was related to point solutions was successful. But there is no progress with mass phenomena – entrepreneurship, takeaway from the "shadow", civic engagement, and so on. Although the government was advised by experts from all over the developed world.
Why? One of the options is that the society is not mature, and the culture hinders it. The society, as an organism, rejects "foreign" solutions so far.
Scientists R. Inglehart and K. Welzel laid out the countries on the "Cultural Map". Two directions of values:
- from traditions to secularism and rationalism;
- from the values of "survival" to the self-expression.
Predictably, Kazakhstan found itself in the lower-left quadrant with moderate traditionalism and a high emphasis on"survival".
This is how it is explained.
- Traditional values (vertically). The importance of religion, family, power, and authority. Divorce, abortion, euthanasia, and suicide are unacceptable. A high level of national pride and nationalism.
- Values of "survival" (horizontally). Emphasis on economic and physical security. Ethnocentrism, low level of trust and patience, tolerance to foreigners, sex minorities. Weak importance of environmental protection, gender equality. Weak participation in economic and political life.
Kazakhstan is located on the border of 2 worlds: Islamic and Orthodox. The same "survivors", but much more secular are Russia and South Korea. The same traditional, but with much more self–expression - the United States, Great Britain, and Canada. Scandinavia, Germany, and Switzerland are further diagonally in both dimensions.
The key conclusion is that we differ from advanced countries even at the cultural level, so it is impossible to plant ready-made recipes. For example, democracy. Without moving "to the right on the map", there will be no demand for democracy. According to Maslow, first of all, people cover up basic needs – physiological and safety - and later start asking for their civil rights.
How to advance on the map? There is no way to do it without economy. The biggest "vertical" jump occurs when transiting from agrarian society to industrial society. The biggest "horizontal" jump occurs when transiting from an industrial society to a knowledge-based economy.
Let's remind you, that 42% of Kazakhstanis still live in rural areas. Almaty and Astana residents are 16% of the population. Only 1.5% of the population receives more than 150 thousand tenge in money (State Commitee).
all publications